Murder, In the Barroom, With the Potato Peeler

This article was scraped from Rochester Subway. This is a blog about Rochester history and urbanism has not been published since 2017. The current owners are now publishing link spam which made me want to preserve this history.. The original article was published December 02, 2015 and can be found here.

     By       Mike Governale

While doing research for a recent story on the     Rochester Marshmallow Company    , we came across another interesting story right around the corner. This one had nothing to do with marshmallows. Wulff's Hotel (shown above) at the corner of State and Factory Streets, was the scene of a notorious murder case...

   Early the morning of December 18, 1920, Thomas Cleary, 44, had given his paycheck to Otto L. Wulff, the hotel's proprietor. Cleary asked Wulff to hold his check until he could return in the afternoon to cash it.

When Cleary returned around 2 p.m., the bartender, Harold "Ducky" Holmes, 32, gave Cleary the check. But here's where the story gets nuts.

Supposedly, for some reason, Holmes called Cleary a "stool pigeon". At that point Cleary became incensed. According to newspaper reports, Cleary walked into the kitchen, grabbed a sharp knife used for peeling potatoes, returned to the barroom and quietly called Holmes over to him. When Holmes came near, Cleary ran the knife through his throat.

The blade made a wound about an inch and a half, severing the jugular vein. Holmes walked a short distance before falling to the floor where he quickly bled to death.

   Cleary, coming to grips with what he had just done, ran out into the street to a nearby beef house where he asked some people to call the police. When police arrived a few minutes later he "calmly admitted to the stabbing, and declared that not only was he perfectly sane but that he would do the same thing again under similar provocation."

When interviewed by detectives, the few men who were in the barroom and kitchen said they heard no argument prior to the stabbing. Cleary and Holmes     had been    friends for a year or so before. And while someone claimed of hearing Cleary ask Holmes how much he owed him, Cleary insisted that he owed no bar bill. He     did    , however, have a "home brew" earlier in the day. Cleary had previously served jail time for public intoxication and vagrancy.

One of the poor kitchen workers would later tell the District Attorney how he regretted having left his potato peeler "in such a convenient spot."

* * *    This story contains historical images from the     Albert R. Stone Negative Collection, Rochester Museum & Science Center, Rochester, NY    .